• Latest
  • Trending
  • All
Analysis: DHL GFF – how to approach a sleeping bear

Analysis: DHL GFF – how to approach a sleeping bear

November 16, 2019
These inventory trackers will notify you when hard-to-find items are back in stock

These inventory trackers will notify you when hard-to-find items are back in stock

April 15, 2020
Antonov An-225 Mriya: world’s largest cargo plane, history, details

Antonov An-225 Mriya: world’s largest cargo plane, history, details

April 15, 2020
Coronavirus | Punjab all set for wheat procurement within lockdown norms

Coronavirus | Punjab all set for wheat procurement within lockdown norms

April 14, 2020
Copperstate Farms Launches International Cannabis Brand DNA Genetics in Arizona Market

Copperstate Farms Launches International Cannabis Brand DNA Genetics in Arizona Market

April 14, 2020
Mzee Moi’s Ksh10B Gift to Gideon

Mzee Moi’s Ksh10B Gift to Gideon

April 14, 2020
Covid Knights: Corporate social purpose in the time of COVID-19

Covid Knights: Corporate social purpose in the time of COVID-19

April 14, 2020
How Tesla And BMW Are Leading A Supply Chain Renaissance With Blockchain

How Tesla And BMW Are Leading A Supply Chain Renaissance With Blockchain

April 14, 2020
Last Mile Delivery Market Worth Observing Growth | UPS, FedEx, SF Express

Last Mile Delivery Market Worth Observing Growth | UPS, FedEx, SF Express

April 14, 2020
LATAM Cargo strengthens European cargo links

LATAM Cargo strengthens European cargo links

April 14, 2020
Labour a worry as Punjab prepares for procurement | Chandigarh News

Labour a worry as Punjab prepares for procurement | Chandigarh News

April 14, 2020
Ford making reusable hospital gowns from airbag materials as efforts against coronavirus expand

Ford making reusable hospital gowns from airbag materials as efforts against coronavirus expand

April 14, 2020
Don’t Sweat NBC’s Decision to Cut Back on Television Ad Inventory

Don’t Sweat NBC’s Decision to Cut Back on Television Ad Inventory

April 14, 2020
  • Supply Chain
  • Logistics
  • Warehousing
  • Procurement
  • Shipping
  • More
    • Strategic Sourcing
    • Spend Analysis
    • Inventory
    • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
United States International Supply Chain Commission
United States International Supply Chain Commission
Home Logistics

Analysis: DHL GFF – how to approach a sleeping bear

by usiscc
November 16, 2019
in Logistics
0
Analysis: DHL GFF – how to approach a sleeping bear
496
SHARES
1.4k
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

bear
By Alessandro Pasetti

15/11/2019

I was in Hamburg this week, where my contacts, rather surprisingly, barely mentioned DHL Global Forwarding, Freight (DHL GFF) and the latest performance of its air, ocean and road freight activities. Perhaps I landed in the wrong city, I silently complained mid-way through its interims on Tuesday.

Most of the talk surrounded DB Schenker and its next corporate structure travails and steps – most likely caused by Berlin rather than self-induced – alongside the prospects of both the major local carrier, Hapag-Lloyd, and top management decisions at AP Møller-Mærsk.

But just as Germany narrowly skirts recession, the resounding success DHL GFF has become after years of struggles surely deserves a mention. Its nine-month results (9M 19) were the brightest for its own comparable corporate data set firmament, setting a new record for the unit in terms of operating earnings (ebit) and operating cash flows (OCF) for this major asset-light business.

The usual caveat is that its numbers are barely acceptable compared to the high standards of its closest peer, Kuehne + Nagel (K+N), although they are a lot less disappointing when compared with its rampant public rival, DSV Panalpina (DSV PAN), which remains virtually indecipherable on a comparable basis, as it lately consolidated only about six weeks of trade and financial data for its newly acquired toy, Panalpina.

As it did in recent quarters – under the leadership of ex-K+N and now DHL GFF CEO Tim Scharwath – DHL GFF shone in the third quarter as part of a group that is holding up nicely, although any bear would be comfortable arguing that the stock market valuation of the Deutsche Post DHL Group (DP-DHL) is justifiable only if extraordinary corporate activity of some kind is on the cards – its mid-term guidance clearly errs on the bullish side of corporate projections, among other things.

Barring DHL GFF, its other three-and-a-half pillars (“e-commerce solutions” has just recently been created) are unlikely to be marked up by investors – there are not comparable public assets against each DP-DHL unit, anyway – so there are few options really on the road to monetisation of assets.

(Source DP-DHL)

(Source DP-DHL)

Now look at the table below: 9M 19 ebit was a whopping €348m, a record for the period since the data became available in 2008 (DP-DHL split up internally its logistics unit, previously comprising supply chain and DHL GFF, effective 1 January 2008).

(Source DP-DHL)

(Source DP-DHL)

Its operating cash flow line was even more stunning at €415m, both in absolute and relative terms.

Cash flow productivity speaks volumes about the level of efficiency that has been sought by Mr Scharwath since mid-2017 – it compares with €410m of (adjusted) OCF in 2012, which was the previous high. Consider that its normalised ebit over the past few years – excluding 9M 19 and 9M 12 highs – stands at about €134m.

(Source DP-DHL)

(Source DP-DHL)

Now its OCF implied a 3x multiple against the average, which inherently means Mr Scharwath’s bidding to make the business more predictable against the volatility of ebit/OCF of the past – even more remarkably (see the tables above and below), this happens as it’s tough out there. These are not the “good days”.

(Source DP-DHL)

(Source DP-DHL)

Bear in mind these comparisons are not perfect throughout the data series – several adjustments must be made, from inorganic considerations to accounting chicaneries and the like. However, a headline regression analysis since 2008 – I can share here a quantitative hand-written summary where the relevant data is highlighted – shows that DHL GFF has grown revenues to €11.2bn from €10.4bn, hence at compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 0.6%, against 1.7% for its ebit.

Take the mid-point of the series before the 2015 annus horribilis (the IT meltdown under Roger Crook), and its earnings growth rate has been either in line or above revenues.

Most comparisons where the final set of ebit data for the nine months of the past two years is left out – hence to 9M 17, pre-Scharwath – would be depressing, but cherry-picking short periods (2012/2011; 2012/2010; 2012 & 2011/2009) where the growth rates were strong, should remind us that we are now in the third year of growth, which may or may not represent peak earnings/cash flow growth, but testifies to the likelihood that incrementally higher returns will be harder to achieve.

Given that, if the sleeping bear wakes up now, DHL GFF being accused of profiting from a great story to market to investors would be the lesser evil.

Another point is that its 3.1% underlying profitability, gauged by ebit/revenues (unadjusted), is back up a little closer to where a leading freight forwarder belongs (there are few public comparables, ex DSV PAN), but still only half way there judging by DSV PAN’s 6%-plus (some recurring items are never recurring with the old DSV, given how it deploys capital externally).

Add DHL GFF’s depreciation and amortisation of €65m quarterly, and its ebitda line in 2019 comes in at €724m.

Stamp on the division a multiple at no discount to DSV PAN’s skyrocketing valuation (~ 18 EV/ebitda; despite the latter’s stronger grow rate, higher margins, no overhang in terms of shareholding structure, yet a lowly yield), and the lightest unit in terms of assets in DP-DHL’s portfolio would be worth 13bn, excluding net debt considerations. (Short note for the reader: there remains a debt pile on the group’s balance sheet, see below – while for DHL GFF, a 2x net leverage in line with its parent might be acceptable) .

(Source DP-DHL)

(Source DP-DHL)

A finance purist would tell you that a €13bn valuation (€14.5bn including net debt) is unfair, given the different prospects of the two, but the German company could become more appealing if it paid a significantly higher dividend rather than chasing M&A growth a la DSV (ex PAN) – it’s worth mentioning that DSV PAN is now worth €22bn on the stock market. And… the Danes trail at some distance in air, where DHL DFF is the global leader, and they are still 300,000 teu away from second-ranked DHL GFF in ocean; also, DHL Freight is much bigger than DSV Road, mainly where they both matter in Europe.

DP-DHL CFO Melanie Kreis knows how to ply her trade, and so does Tim Scharwath, while market consensus says CEO Frank Appel is pleased with both executive board members and with the way things are going business-wise. But group debt must come down. While Berlin rules on that front, they are all aware that DHL GFF monetisation is possible, as well as that DSV PAN’s success boils down to a lack of alternative choices for investors in the freight forwarding world, following the de-listings of PAN and Ceva in the past year.

Share198Tweet124Share50
usiscc

usiscc

  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
Antonov An-225 Mriya: world’s largest cargo plane, history, details

Antonov An-225 Mriya: world’s largest cargo plane, history, details

April 15, 2020
3 keys to mitigating severe supply shortages from coronavirus disruption

3 keys to mitigating severe supply shortages from coronavirus disruption

March 18, 2020
Corteva responding to changes in agriculture supply chain | 2020-03-06

Corteva responding to changes in agriculture supply chain | 2020-03-06

March 6, 2020
These inventory trackers will notify you when hard-to-find items are back in stock

These inventory trackers will notify you when hard-to-find items are back in stock

0
Global Industry Analysis, Size, Share, Growth, Trends, and Forecasts 2016–2024 – ZMR News Reports

Global Industry Analysis, Size, Share, Growth, Trends, and Forecasts 2016–2024 – ZMR News Reports

0
PHOTOS: Ottawa firefighters respond to warehouse fire

PHOTOS: Ottawa firefighters respond to warehouse fire

0
These inventory trackers will notify you when hard-to-find items are back in stock

These inventory trackers will notify you when hard-to-find items are back in stock

April 15, 2020
Antonov An-225 Mriya: world’s largest cargo plane, history, details

Antonov An-225 Mriya: world’s largest cargo plane, history, details

April 15, 2020
Coronavirus | Punjab all set for wheat procurement within lockdown norms

Coronavirus | Punjab all set for wheat procurement within lockdown norms

April 14, 2020
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Disclaimer
  • DMCA
  • Contact Us

Copyright © 2021 United States International Supply Chain Commission (usiscc.org)

No Result
View All Result
  • Supply Chain
  • Logistics
  • Warehousing
  • Procurement
  • Shipping
  • More
    • Strategic Sourcing
    • Spend Analysis
    • Inventory
    • Contact Us

Copyright © 2021 United States International Supply Chain Commission (usiscc.org)

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Cookie settingsACCEPT
Privacy & Cookies Policy

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled

Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.

Non-necessary

Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.